The best time to plant garlic is between mid October and mid November. Set the separated cloves pointed end up, 5 to 10 centimetres deep, with 10 to 15 centimetres between cloves in the row and 25 to 30 centimetres between rows. You harvest them the following year in June or July. The reason autumn works better than spring: garlic needs a cold period of roughly two months before a single clove will split into a full bulb in spring. Source: GroentenInfo
That last bit is the whole story in one sentence. Plant too late, plant supermarket garlic, or harvest too late, and you end up with one fat round bulb with no cloves in it, or a bulb that is already going mouldy after six weeks.
Below you will find the lot: which type to choose and why it matters, how to prepare the ground, the full step-by-step method, what to do month by month, the exact moment to harvest (this is the mistake almost everyone makes), how to cure and store, and how to select your own seed garlic so you never have to buy again.
Why autumn beats spring
Garlic is not a seed. You plant a clove, and that clove has to do something rather special: in spring it has to split into eight to twelve new cloves that together form one bulb.
That split does not happen on its own. The plant needs a trigger, and that trigger is cold. The technical term is vernalisation. Without enough cold weeks your clove will still grow into a plant, but it will not divide. What you harvest is a single round bulb with no cloves. Edible, but not what you were after.
How much cold? Reckon on roughly two months at low temperatures. In a normal British winter you get that for free if you plant in October or November. Source: GroentenInfo
Then there is the second advantage: time. Garlic that goes into the ground in October builds a solid root system before the frosts arrive. Come spring, that plant is months ahead of a clove that only starts in March. You can see it in the size of the bulb. Autumn planted garlic almost always gives bigger bulbs than spring planted garlic.
So when do you plant in spring?
There is one situation: heavy, wet clay that sits waterlogged all winter. Garlic hates wet feet. If your bed is under water from December to March, your seed cloves rot away before spring even starts. Plant in March instead, or build your bed up into raised ridges (more on that shortly).
Simply forgot to plant in autumn? Spring planting in March still works. Do pick a variety sold as spring garlic though, because those need less cold. Your bulbs will be smaller, but you will get a harvest.
| Autumn planting | Spring planting | |
|---|---|---|
| Planting time | mid October to mid November | March |
| Harvest | June to July | July to August |
| Bulb size | large | smaller |
| Cold trigger | from the winter | often not enough |
| Risk | rot on wet, cold clay | drought in June |
| Suits | almost everyone | wet clay, or if you left it too late |
Hardneck or softneck: choose deliberately
There are two main groups of garlic, and most gardeners have no idea which one they are putting in the ground. That explains a lot of disappointment.
Hardneck sends up a firm, woody flower stem from the middle of the plant in spring. That stem is called a scape and it has to come out (see further down). Hardneck usually gives fewer but larger cloves, in a single ring around the hard stem. The flavour tends to be more pronounced. The downside: hardneck does not keep as long.
Softneck produces no flower stem. The foliage stays floppy, which is exactly why you can plait softneck into those garlic braids you see hanging in southern Europe. Softneck gives more but smaller cloves, arranged in several layers. Big plus: softneck stores far longer, often well into the following spring.
| Hardneck | Softneck | |
|---|---|---|
| Flower stem (scape) | yes, has to come out | no |
| Cloves per bulb | usually 4 to 8, larger | usually 10 to 20, smaller |
| Peeling | easy | a bit more work |
| Storage life | shorter | long |
| Plaiting | no | yes |
| Hardiness | generally tough | also fine, but slightly more tender |
| Best for | flavour, using fresh | a store cupboard that lasts to spring |
So which do you pick? If you want garlic right through to next spring: plant mostly softneck and a smaller amount of hardneck for the flavour and the scapes. Just want to give it a go? Take both, because it is no extra work.
Varieties you will come across at seed garlic suppliers include Oosterdel, Morado, Sulmona, Inchelium Red, German Stiffneck and Purple Glazer. Source: Diana’s mooie moestuin Some growers hold dozens of varieties in their collection, so once you get a taste for it you can experiment for years.
Never plant supermarket garlic
This is the biggest beginner trap, and it looks so tempting: there is a bulb in your kitchen drawer that has started sprouting, so into the ground it goes. Three reasons not to.
1. Wrong variety. Supermarket garlic often comes from Spain, Argentina or China. Those varieties are selected for a climate with different day lengths and different winters. Here they perform badly, or they do not split at all.
2. Possible sprout inhibitors. Garlic grown for storage is sometimes treated so it does not sprout on the shelf. Handy in the kitchen and useless in the ground.
3. Disease risk. And this is the serious one. Imported garlic can bring soil diseases into your garden that you will never get rid of, white rot first among them. The fungus behind white rot (Sclerotium cepivorum) survives for years in the soil and makes a plot practically unusable for the entire onion family. Source: Moestuin Stekjes
So buy seed garlic from a specialist supplier. It costs more than a bulb off the shelf, but do the sums: one planting bulb gives you eight to twelve cloves, and therefore eight to twelve new bulbs. Some organic seed garlic suppliers pack specifically for home gardeners in small quantities, for instance in lots of 0.4 kilos, which works out at around five bulbs. Source: Bouma Biologisch Poot- en Plantgoed
And after that first year you never have to buy again, because you select your own seed garlic. How that works is at the bottom of this article.
How much should you plant? Do the sums
Simple maths, because this is where it often goes wrong: people plant ten cloves and have run out by September.
One clove gives one bulb. So: count how many bulbs you get through in a week, multiply by 52, and add 10 percent for losses and next year’s seed.
| Use | Bulbs per year | Cloves to plant | Space needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cook now and then | around 25 | 30 | around 1 m² |
| Normal household (1 bulb a week) | around 52 | 60 | around 2 m² |
| Cook a lot, proper enthusiast | around 100 | 110 | around 3.5 m² |
At 12 centimetres in the row and 28 centimetres between rows you get roughly 30 plants per square metre. Garlic is remarkably economical with space, and the bed is occupied from November to July, after which you can still fit in a follow-on crop (kale, endive or lamb’s lettuce, for example).
Preparing the ground
Garlic asks for only three things, and all three matter.
1. Crop rotation: one year in five for the whole onion family
This is not a gentle suggestion. For the allium family (garlic, onion, shallot, leek, chives) the rule is a rotation of one year in five, precisely to stop nematodes and soil fungi building up. Source: Diana’s mooie moestuin
In practice: wherever your onions or leeks stood this year, no garlic for the next four years. If you have a small garden, just draw up a plan and pin it in your shed. Five beds, five crop groups, shift one place along each year.
2. Drainage: this is where most harvests are lost
Garlic sits in the ground for eight months, including the wettest months of the year. A spot that is waterlogged in January is a spot where your seed cloves will rot away.
Not sure? Do the simple test: dig a hole a spade deep, fill it with water, and see how long it stands. If it is still full after a few hours, you have a drainage problem.
The fix on heavy or wet ground: build your garlic bed up into ridges 15 to 20 centimetres high. Or use a raised bed. It genuinely makes a difference, because the clove then sits above the level where the water stands.
3. No fresh manure, but plenty of well rotted compost
Fresh or unrotted farmyard manure under garlic gives you two problems: too much nitrogen (lush foliage, soft bulb, poor keeping) and a higher risk of rot. Work well rotted compost into the top layer instead, two to three centimetres spread over the bed and lightly raked in.
Garlic wants an open, humus rich soil. Source: Diana’s mooie moestuin
And pick a sunny spot. Too little sun gives small bulbs.
The method: planting garlic in 8 steps
What you need: seed garlic, a dibber or narrow hoe, a tape measure or planting line, well rotted compost, and mesh or fleece against birds if needed.
Step 1. Wait for the right moment. Mid October to mid November is the window. The rule of thumb: the cloves need to be able to root before the frost arrives, but should not put much growth above ground yet. Source: Diana’s mooie moestuin Planting too early (August, September) gives too much leaf going into winter, and that gets frosted back.
Step 2. Get the bed level and weed free. Garlic is a poor competitor against weeds. Narrow leaves, very little shade. Whatever you leave standing now costs you yield in May. Get all the perennial weed roots out too.
Step 3. Break the bulb up at the last moment. Split the bulb into individual cloves just before planting. Do not do it days in advance, because the broken surfaces dry out. Leave the brown papery skin on each clove.
Step 4. Sort and select. Plant only the fat, unblemished outer cloves. Big clove gives big bulb. The small inner cloves, and anything with spots, soft patches or mould, goes to the kitchen, not into the ground.
Step 5. Mark out the rows. Row spacing 25 to 30 centimetres, 10 to 15 centimetres within the row. Source: Diana’s mooie moestuin Wider spacing gives bigger bulbs, closer spacing gives more bulbs. At 12 centimetres you are right in the middle.
Step 6. Plant pointed end up. This is not optional. The point is the growing end, the broad flat end is the root end. Garlic planted upside down will still come up, but it does so via a bend, and gives a crooked, smaller bulb.
Depth: 5 to 10 centimetres, measured to the top of the clove.
| Soil type | Planting depth | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Light sandy soil | 8 to 10 cm | dries out faster, more risk of frost heave |
| Normal garden soil | 6 to 8 cm | the standard |
| Heavy or wet clay | 5 cm, on a raised ridge | deeper is wetter, wetter is rot |
| Pot or container | 5 to 7 cm, at least 20 cm pot depth | otherwise too little root room |
Do not press the clove into the soil, because that compacts the ground underneath, exactly where the roots need to go. Make a hole with a dibber, drop the clove in, and fill the hole.
Step 7. Cover up and keep the birds off. Pigeons, jackdaws and blackbirds will pull freshly planted cloves straight back out. Lay fleece or mesh over the bed until the shoots are about 5 centimetres above the ground. Source: Gardeners World
Step 8. No water and no feed. Autumn soil is damp enough. Feeding waits until spring, because nitrogen now gives you leaf you do not want going into winter.
What do you do over winter?
Very little, and that is exactly the point. Three things to keep an eye on though.
Foliage in winter. It is perfectly normal to see green tips 5 to 10 centimetres above the ground in December and January. That is fine. If the leaf gets frosted back, do not panic: the plant is in the clove and will simply push up again in March.
Mulch: useful, but with judgement. A layer of straw or shredded leaves 3 to 5 centimetres deep keeps the soil temperature steadier, holds down weeds and prevents frost heave (where frost slowly pushes the clove upwards). Do it after the first proper frost, not before. Important: pull the mulch off or draw it aside in March, otherwise you hold too much moisture and encourage slugs and rot.
Have a walk round after a cold spell. If you spot cloves that have been pushed up, press them back in or cover them with a bit of soil.
The growing calendar: month by month
| Month | What you do |
|---|---|
| September | prepare the bed, work in compost, order seed garlic |
| October to mid November | plant, netting over the top |
| December to January | nothing, mulch after the first frost if you want |
| February | loosen the mulch, weed as soon as you can |
| March | first feed (nitrogen), take the mulch off |
| April | weed, second feed as the bulbs start forming |
| May | potassium for bulb development, water in dry spells, stop the nitrogen |
| June | harvest scapes on hardneck, ease off the watering |
| June to July | harvest as soon as a third to half the foliage is yellow |
| July to August | cure, sort, set aside seed garlic |
Feeding in short: no feed at planting, a general feed with nitrogen in February or March so the plant gets a good start on leaf, and extra potassium in April or May for bulb development. Source: Moesmeisje Stop the nitrogen around mid May, because nitrogen at the end of the run gives soft bulbs that keep badly.
Water in spring during dry spells, but ease off as soon as the bulbs start filling. Garlic that is still getting plenty of water just before harvest keeps less well and is more prone to rot. Last three weeks before harvest: keep it dry.
Scapes: the bonus harvest most people throw away
If you planted hardneck, a woody stem shoots up in June with a curled end and a bud on it. That is the scape, the flower stem.
Take it out. For as long as it stands there, energy goes into a flower instead of into your bulb. Remove it as early as you can, while it is still curling, either by pulling it out or cutting it off just above the top leaf. Source: Diana’s mooie moestuin
And now the good bit: the scape is delicious. Mild garlic flavour, crisp like asparagus. Stir fry it, grill it, or turn it into pesto. For a lot of people this is the tastiest thing the garlic plant produces, and it is exactly the part most gardeners chuck on the compost heap.
The appearance of the scapes is also a clock, by the way: once they show up, you know harvest is about three to four weeks away.
When to harvest: this is where it usually goes wrong
Ask ten people when you harvest garlic and nine will say: when the foliage is yellow. That is not quite right, and the difference costs you your entire store.
The rule: harvest when roughly a third to half of the leaves have gone brown or yellow from the bottom up, while the top four to five leaves are still green. In practice that is often late June or early July with an autumn planting.
Why not later? Every green leaf on the plant corresponds to one wrapper skin around your bulb. If you wait until all the foliage is dead, those outer skins have rotted away. Your bulb then falls apart into loose cloves as you lift it, and without intact skins it keeps really badly. A bulb harvested too late will not last you six months.
Why not earlier? The cloves are not fully grown yet and the bulb cures poorly.
The test bulb. Not sure? Lift one. Check whether the cloves are clearly separated and whether the bulb has a tight skin. If the cloves have not separated yet, put the soil back and wait a week.
How to lift. Do not pull on the foliage, because the neck snaps off and you end up with a bulb that never cures properly. Push a digging fork into the ground 10 centimetres away from the plant, lever the soil loose and lift the bulb out. Knock the soil off gently. Do not wash it and do not scrub it.
Pick a dry day. Best moment: after a run of a few dry days, so the soil comes away with it.
Curing and storing
This is the step that decides whether you still have garlic in February.
Curing takes three to four weeks. Hang the plants in bunches with the foliage still on, or lay them on a rack, somewhere dry and airy. Source: Diana’s mooie moestuin An open shed, a carport or the space under a lean-to works perfectly well.
Three rules for curing:
- Air circulation matters more than warmth. Garlic packed tightly together will go mouldy.
- Not in full sun. Sun scorch damages the skins and creates rot spots. Shade with plenty of air movement is ideal.
- Keep it out of the rain. One decent downpour halfway through curing costs you the batch.
You know it is done when the neck is completely dry and closed, the roots feel stiff and dry, and the outer skins rustle.
Then clean them up. Trim the roots to half a centimetre and the foliage to about 3 centimetres above the bulb, or leave the foliage on and plait the softneck bulbs into a string.
Storing. Dry and dark, with a bit of air movement. A net, a basket or a plaited string in the utility room, garage or shed. The most important tip: do not put garlic in the fridge. Fridge temperature is precisely where garlic sprouts fastest, which makes the cloves soft and bitter. Cool and dry is good, ice cold and damp is not.
| Type | Realistic storage life with good curing |
|---|---|
| Softneck | 6 to 10 months |
| Hardneck | 4 to 6 months |
So use your hardneck first, and save the softneck for the late season.
Selecting your own seed garlic: buy once, then it is free
This is the point where garlic gets genuinely satisfying. When you are cleaning up the harvest, do this:
- Set aside the biggest, cleanest bulbs with the most fat cloves. Reckon on around 10 percent of your harvest.
- Pick bulbs from plants that grew healthily, so no rust spots and no early yellowing.
- Keep them as whole bulbs, unpeeled, until your planting date in October.
- Note down which variety came from where if you grow several types.
What happens is this: every year you select for whatever does best in your soil, in your climate. After a few seasons you have a line adapted to your garden. It is the cheapest form of plant breeding there is.
One caveat: refresh your own line now and then. Bring in new certified seed garlic every four to five years, because viruses build up slowly in your own material and you notice it in declining bulb size.
Diseases and problems: spotting them and dealing with them
Rust
Orange to reddish brown pustules on the leaf. Rust is a fungal disease that spreads by spores and affects the whole onion family. The infection limits photosynthesis and weakens the plant, which shows up in bulb size. It spreads mainly in damp weather with temperatures between 15 and 20 degrees. Source: Tuinadvies
What to do: always clear away crop debris (do not compost it), space plants generously so the leaves dry off quickly, water at the base rather than over the foliage, and keep alliums off the bed for part of the year. With a light infection late in the season you can often just carry on growing and harvest slightly early.
White rot
The dangerous one. Yellowing leaves, wilting, and on the base of the bulb a white, watery fungal fluff with black granules in it. Caused by Sclerotium cepivorum, a soil fungus that can attack garlic at any growth stage. Source: Moestuin Stekjes
There is no treatment. The black granules (sclerotia) survive in the soil for years. Prevention is everything: a rotation of several years, good drainage and clean seed garlic only. If you do get it: lift the diseased plants complete with their rootball, put them in the general waste and grow no onions, leeks or garlic on that plot for years. Anyone who really cannot shake it off grows garlic in pots or containers with fresh compost. Source: Gardeners World
Stem nematodes
Swollen, distorted foliage, and bulbs that go soft and mealy from the base up. Nematodes arrive with infected seed garlic and stay in the soil for a long time. Which is exactly why a one in five rotation and reliable seed garlic are not luxuries.
Bulb does not split (one round bulb)
The classic cause: not enough cold, so planted too late or a variety that does not suit our climate. Too much nitrogen late in the season can contribute as well. Plant in October next year with a variety meant for autumn planting and it is sorted. The round bulb is perfectly edible, by the way.
Bulbs stay small
Four usual causes, in order of how often they crop up: too many weeds, too little sun, too small a seed clove planted, or scapes not removed on hardneck. And sometimes: too dry in May, just as the bulb is filling.
The 8 mistakes most people make
- Planting supermarket garlic. Wrong variety, possible sprout inhibitor, disease risk.
- Planting upside down. Pointed end up, always.
- Planting the small inner cloves too. Small clove gives small bulb. Those go in the pan.
- Planting too early in September. Too much leaf going into winter.
- Fresh manure under the garlic. Soft bulbs, rot, poor keeping.
- Not weeding in spring. Garlic loses every fight for light and water.
- Harvesting too late. Bulb falls apart, no skins, will not keep.
- Curing badly. Three weeks of airy curing is not optional, it is a condition.
Garlic in a pot or container
Works perfectly well, and it is also your way out if you have white rot in the garden.
- Pot size: at least 20 centimetres deep, ideally 25 to 30. The width determines the number: a 15 centimetre pot takes about 3 cloves, a 30 centimetre pot about 6. Source: Gardeners World
- Compost: potting compost mixed with a bit of garden compost and a handful of sharp sand or perlite for drainage.
- Drainage: holes in the base, and stand the pot on feet or bricks so it is not sitting in water.
- Winter: leave the pot outside, because the plant needs that cold. Do stand it against a wall so the rootball does not freeze solid all the way through.
- Water: almost nothing over winter, moderate in spring.
Expect slightly smaller bulbs than in open ground, but it works.
Frequently asked questions
When should I plant garlic?
Between mid October and mid November. In that window the cloves still root before the frost arrives, without putting much growth above ground. If you have left it too late, you can still plant spring garlic in March, but expect smaller bulbs.
How deep do you plant garlic?
Five to ten centimetres deep, pointed end up. On light sandy soil you can go deeper (8 to 10 centimetres), on heavy or wet clay stick to about 5 centimetres and build the bed up into a raised ridge so the cloves are not sitting in the wet.
Can I plant supermarket garlic?
Better not. Supermarket garlic is often a variety from a different climate, may have been treated to stop it sprouting, and can bring in soil diseases that stay in your garden for years, white rot among them. Buy seed garlic from a specialist supplier. After that first year you can use your own bulbs as seed.
When do I harvest the garlic?
When roughly a third to half of the foliage has gone yellow or brown from the bottom up, while the top four to five leaves are still green. With an autumn planting that is usually late June or early July. If you wait until all the foliage is dead, the bulb falls apart and keeps badly.
Why has my garlic not formed cloves?
Then the plant did not get enough cold. Garlic needs a cold period of roughly two months to split in spring. Planted too late, or a variety from a warmer climate, gives one round bulb with no cloves. It is perfectly edible, but plant in October next year with a variety meant for autumn planting.
How long does home grown garlic keep?
With good curing (three to four weeks, airy and dry) softneck lasts around 6 to 10 months and hardneck around 4 to 6 months. Store dry, dark and cool with a bit of air circulation, and not in the fridge, because fridge temperature is exactly where garlic sprouts quickly.
Do I need to cover garlic over winter?
Usually not, because garlic is properly hardy. A layer of straw or leaves 3 to 5 centimetres deep after the first frost can help against frost heave though, and it keeps weeds down. Take that mulch off again in March, otherwise you hold too much moisture.
Can I grow garlic next to other crops?
Yes, and it combines well with crops that do not need the bed until late in spring. Keep it away from other alliums (onion, leek, shallot) because of disease pressure and rotation. After the July harvest you have plenty of time for a follow-on crop such as kale, endive or lamb’s lettuce.
In short: plant in October or November, pointed end up, 5 to 10 centimetres deep, with 10 to 15 centimetres in the row. Buy proper seed garlic, make sure your ground drains, weed in spring and harvest as soon as a third of the foliage is yellow. Three weeks of airy curing and you have your own garlic well into the following year.
The best part: out of those first bulbs you buy, you only need to set a few aside and you are sorted for good.
Want to develop your vegetable garden further, with raised beds, a cold frame or a greenhouse? At Fred’s DIY Plans you will find worked out plans for raised beds, garden sheds and garden structures, complete with a materials list and step-by-step instructions. Have a look here.
Best regards from Fred Schouten, builder and DIYer through and through
PS: order your seed garlic in August or September. The interesting varieties are already sold out by October, and then you are back in the supermarket aisle wondering. Small tip. Big difference.


